Issue 22: Women, Intimate Partner Violence, & Homelessness

 

This newsletter will:

  • Explain the connections between IPV and homelessness
  • Identify barriers to safe, secure, accessible, and affordable housing when fleeing violence
  • Discuss the impacts of IPV and housing issues through women’s narratives
  • Highlight the resilience of women

Please click here to evaluate this newsletter.

Issue 22: Women, Intimate Partner Violence, and Homelessness Newsletter cover pageView Printable PDF
View Plaintext PDF

 

 

40% of people in Canada experiencing visible homelessness – living in shelters or rough sleeping – are women[1]

25% of those women cited domestic abuse as a factor leading to their most recent housing loss[2]

While the circumstances around individuals seeking shelter are complex and varied, we know that oppressive structures, such as economic injustice, racism, and sexism, play a key role. These systemic forces interact to shape the experiences of women living with intimate partner violence (IPV) and housing issues. The narratives in this newsletter come from the courageous women who shared their stories with advocates and researchers that work to bring greater understanding and attention to this serious social issue.

DEFINITIONS

Intimate Partner Violence includes physical, sexual, or psychological harm by a current or former partner or spouse. IPV is predominantly perpetuated by men and against women.

Women have diverse and intersecting social identities depending on their age, social class, gender identity, sexual identity, race, culture, Indigeneity, physical and mental abilities, and other features.[3] Women self-identify and express their gender and sexuality in a variety of ways. Our organization and this newsletter are inclusive of trans, gender expansive, and two-spirit women.

Homelessness refers to “the situation of an individual or family without stable, permanent, appropriate housing, or the immediate prospect, means, and ability of acquiring it.”[4]

Narratives throughout this issue are used with permission. We are grateful to the researchers and the women who shared their experiences.

BRINGING INTERSECTIONALITY TO THE ISSUE

Intersectionality is a useful framework for examining how forms of privilege and disadvantage shape women’s experiences of violence and homelessness, and their access to resources and supports.

Fundamental to this framework is understanding social location, including that individuals belong to various groups or communities. Kimberlé Crenshaw describes how groups or communities intersect to influence an individual’s social location and the way one experiences the world.[5] For instance, social class, gender, sexual identification, race, culture, disability, economic status, education, religion, age, immigration status, and occupation all contribute to social location.

An individual may face oppression based on their social location. Oppression produces inequality, exclusion, fear, and violence. It is created and reinforced through harmful social norms, practices, and institutions.

An intersectional approach tells us that the experiences of various groups of women will differ based on factors such as race, disability, age, sexual orientation, etc. These intersecting social locations and associated oppressions shape experiences of violence, homelessness, support seeking, and responses from services.

Click here for video on intersectionality with subtitles.

We start with this core newsletter to set the stage and highlight the main links between homelessness and violence. Next will be a newsletter developed by women with lived experience so as to center their knowledge and highlight their narratives.

Four additional newsletters complete the series. Each is a piece of intersectional work and thought that focuses on groups often overlooked or given minimal attention, and who experience additional barriers when fleeing violence and seeking safe, secure, accessible, and affordable housing:

  • Indigenous Women
  • LGBTIQ2S Youth
  • Immigrant and Refugee Women
  • Women Living with Disabilities and Deaf Women

UPCOMING NEWSLETTERS

  • Women’s Voices
  • LGBTIQ2S Youth, Homelessness, and Violence with Dr. Alex Abramovich (Centre for Addiction and Mental Health)
  • Indigenous Women, Homelessness, and Violence with the Ontario Native Women’s Association
  • Immigrant and Refugee Women, Homelessness, and Violence with the Ontario Council Of Agencies Serving Immigrants
  • Women Living with Disabilities and Deaf Women, Homelessness, and Violence with the DisAbled Women’s Network of Canada

Get these newsletters direct to your inbox by joining our mailing list - just send a request to vawln@uwo.ca!

Click here to read our newsletter on intersectionality.

HOUSING IS ALWAYS AN ISSUE WHEN A WOMAN IS NOT SAFE IN HER HOME

These are some thoughts and considerations women have when fleeing violence:

  • I am not emotionally, physically, or sexually safe in my house.
  • Does the shelter accept trans women? Will I encounter transphobia in the shelter?
  • Will my belongings be thrown outside tonight?
  • Will my partner follow me?
  • I live on reserve and his sister suns the shelter. Everyone will know.
  • Can my 14-year-old son come? He doesn’t want to, but I can’t leave him with my partner. What about my pets?
  • Will the shelter be accessible? Will I be put into an institution because there is no accessible housing with supports?
  • Is it really safe in shelters? I’ve heard stories… What about the violence on the streets?
  • How can I afford to live on my own?
  • Where will I go? How long can I stay?
  • Will going to shelter affect my immigration status?
  • The nearest shelter is 4 hours away – how will I commute to work?
  • Why do I have to be the one to leave?

WHAT CAN A HOUSING ISSUE LOOK LIKE FOR A WOMAN?

Many women do not experience just one form of housing issue. Rather, the instability of their housing is felt in different ways depending on a multitude of factors including violence, race, immigration status, disability, and geographic location.

Her housing difficulties may be visible

  • Her belongings are thrown outside by her partner and she sleeps in a tent.
  • “I lived under the bridge for three months... under the bridge, no blankets, having to sleep on rock and eat wherever you could, having to panhandle. Going to different churches, where you line up to be the first one to eat, for a good shower. There are lice in your hair.”[6]
  • She stays in an emergency shelter with men and women for 2 days.
  • She lives in domestic violence transitional housing for 3 months.

Or it may be hidden

  • She loses her house while in hospital for physical abuse from her partner, and has nowhere to go once discharged.
  • She sleeps on a couch in an already overcrowded home.
  • “I stayed with one friend but she was such a drug addict that I would rather be on the street. It was horrible. It was crack cocaine and the house was dirty… I slept on a dirty mattress, a dirty pillow. I was scared that some guy was gonna come in my room; the door was kicked off.”[7]
  • She engages in survival sex in exchange for a roof over her head.

Even when she has housing, it may be unaffordable, inaccessible, & unsafe

  • She may only be able to afford rent by paying it over bills, food, and other needs (e.g. hygiene products).
  • The house is not accessible to her as she is living with a physical disability.
  • “I was living in a big house but without peace because I was abused. Even the kids were abused. Mentally. Physically. Sexually. Every which way. And it didn’t matter what size of house it is. It’s the condition of living.”[8]
  • She is unsafe in her house due to threats of violence and confinement by her partner.

A POEM OF LIVED EXPERIENCE

My Home

The lights that shine so bright at night
Home on the streets just isn’t right
The sound of the cars as they pass by
Try to relax, at least I try
Sleeping in doorways, no way to live

To have a home what I wouldn’t give
Those cold winter nights that lie ahead
Life on the streets is what I dread
People pass by like they just don’t care
Life for some just isn’t fair
A home is a necessity would you not agree
To have respect and dignity

Maggie Traynor

Women’s Voices newsletter coming soon! Subscribe to our mailing list to have it delivered to your inbox - send your request to: vawln@uwo.ca

WHAT BARRIERS TO SAFE, SECURE, ACCESSIBLE, AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING EXIST FOR WOMEN FLEEING VIOLENCE?

Poverty reduces options for a woman experiencing violence and may stem from her partner withholding wages, work absences due to abuse, low wages, precarious employment, and a lack of services and programs assisting women fleeing violence.[9]

“I remember I would have to change my PIN number all the time because he would make me give him my PIN number and he would take all the money out of the account.”[10]

Shortage of affordable housing means that the housing that is available costs more than what is considered reasonable for most people. In Canada, housing that takes less than 30% of one’s pay is considered affordable. When housing costs are more than that, the risk of homelessness increases, especially for women fleeing violence.

- 1 in 4 households spend more than what is considered affordable on housing
- 4 out of 10 renters spend more than what is affordable[12]

Discrimination affects women’s ability to obtain housing and employment. For instance, the Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation has found that landlords discriminate against women fleeing IPV, thus making their housing search even more difficult and limited.[13]

Transgender youth, in particular trans women of colour, face some of the highest levels of discrimination when seeking housing and shelter.[14]

“Landlords were almost 10 times less likely to indicate that a rental unit was available to a caller staying at a shelter for battered women.”[15]

Lack of shelters for transitioning from an abusive house to a safe, secure, affordable, and accessible home can result in women being turned away from shelters. When a woman cannot stay in shelter, she may sleep in her car or on the streets. If the shelter is not accessible, a woman living with a disability may be sent to the local hospital or a long-term care facility if there are no other options.

On April 16th, 2014: 338 women and 201 children were turned away from women’s shelters.[16]

Out of those turned away, 56% were due to the shelter being full.[17]

Lack of accessible shelters is felt especially by women fleeing violence in rural, remote, and Northern communities.[18]

Impacts of abuse and other stressors compromise a woman’s search for housing when leaving violence. Finding housing is stressful at the best of times. However, women experiencing IPV are trying to find housing while navigating the obstacles and risks generated by an abusive partner, such as threats against her and her children, stalking, withholding of money, and destruction of property.

“I had three places and my partner would find out. He’d promise that he would smarten up and then the same thing. I got evicted. I’d get another place; he’d try to kick the door down. I got evicted. The last time he started fighting me. I got evicted. I got tired of forever moving and buying stuff; everything gets thrown out or he sells it.”[19]

Compounded barriers are experienced by some groups of women who face oppression related to race/ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, ability, age, social class, etc. A woman who is discriminated against due to her race, disability, sex, or gender has additional difficulties in securing housing and employment.[20]

Cheryl is an immigrant from China who lives with a disability. When Cheryl leaves her abusive partner she makes active efforts to find a new house, but she needs a house that meets accessibility standards and she has trouble finding one.

When Cheryl is able to find a house that meets her needs, the landlord asks her various questions around why an immigrant woman would leave her partner who sponsored them and about the financial assistance Cheryl receives through the Ontario Disability Support Program. The landlord decides not to rent to Cheryl.

CHERYL FACES ABLEISM, RACISM, SEXISM, AND CLASSISM.

Exploring the Intersections: Immigrant and refugee women fleeing violence and experiencing homelessness in Canada - This 2017 report explores the intersections between immigrant and refugee women fleeing violence and experiencing homelessness, health/mental health and disability issues, and trauma in Canada.

CHANGING NARRATIVES

Narratives around women fleeing violence and experiencing homelessness present homelessness as the fault of women, with a focus on weakness and damage, rather than recognizing the broader systemic conditions that create barriers for women to obtain and secure long-term housing.

WOMEN’S NARRATIVES BRING IMPACTS TO LIFE

Impacts of violence and homelessness can be visible, invisible, short-term, and long-term. Supports are needed before, during, and after housing is secured to assist with healing and transitions.

Employment Difficulties “That’s another pressure. I really would like to move out but I can’t because before I don’t find a job so it’s kind of this circle. So I feel since a while a little bit depressed.”[21]

Revictimization – “Guys see you walking around with a black eye, then figure they can abuse you too. You’ve got to be very careful. I didn’t want to go downtown cause I was scared I was gonna get raped or drugged. Or, some guys gonna beat the shit out of me and get me to be a prostitute. Because I’m on the street, I’m vulnerable.”[22]

Substance Use – “I became an alcoholic; I chose that life. I thought, maybe it’s the way for me to get out. Now I know it’s not. Alcohol does kill you. If not, somebody or something will kill you.”[23]

Health Difficulties (e.g. physical health issues, mental health issues, reproductive health issues) – “It was stressful, having migraines all the time. I am the kind of person that only very rarely I get sick with a cold. And I was constantly getting sick with that. It felt like my immune system was just going down. Plus I was overeating, Oh, I had low self-esteem, where I felt that I couldn’t accomplish anything.”[24]

Loss – “I came back to my house. I had my kids’ Christmas presents and bought a huge tree. The shelter donated some furniture and it was nice. He put gas all over and set my place on fire and stayed in the house. He was trying to kill himself.”[25]

Compromised Parenting Potential – “I had one kid. We ended up getting kicked out of an apartment because there was too much fighting and drinking on his [ex-partner] part. We ended up on the streets. It was pretty scary; I thought I was gonna lose my son. Three weeks we stayed from place to place and I knew that wasn’t stable for my son.”[26]

Lack of Psychological Safety – “My current housing suits me very well, I like the independence, I like to have my own space, I feel comfortable here but I don’t feel safe.” [27]

Financial Problems – “I was working and paying this girl a whole bunch of money, like for daycare and stuff and like, right, and so I’m like, yeah, I’m not making ends meet either even though I am in housing and my, my costs have gone up a bit, it’s not market rent, but I was spending all this money on daycare... So I’m like, sure, come here for a month and then watch the kids for me, I’ll give you a bit of money, and find a place to stay. And then I got the crap kicked out of me.”[28]

“I’ll never forget the day that I found out that we were evicted. I found the eviction notice in the glove box. He had been lying to me since October that he was paying the rent. We were in March. He got the eviction notice back, I believe it was end of February or early March. I got the letter like March 5 and they were going to be changing the locks with the sheriff on March 12. I was pregnant.”[29]

WOMEN ARE RESILIENT

Click for video of Rupi Kaur with subtitles.

“It takes a broken, twisted person to come searching for meaning between my legs, but it takes a whole, complete, perfectly designed person to survive it.

It takes monsters to steal souls, and fighters to reclaim them.

This home is what I came into the world with; was the first home, will be the last home.

You can’t take it.”
- Rupi Kaur in I’m Taking My Body Back

Women have “the ability to succeed in the face of adversity” and to work with supports to heal and help those around them.[30] Resilience is not obtained in a single “a-ha” moment. Women experience extremely difficult times and setbacks. In spite of these adversities and even when things are at their worst, resilience exists and can be strengthened.

Resilience is in “the doing.”[31] It requires action, moving, and relating. At times, it will require experimentation so that a woman’s individual path to strengthened resilience can be found. Some possible routes include mentoring, peer support, safe spaces, culture, religion, and personal support networks. Women benefit when informal and formal supports recognize a woman’s potential and work with her to build on her strengths, like her passion for dance or her sharing through writing.

THE RESILIENCE OF MOTHERS

Mothers experiencing homelessness continually note the importance of their children in their efforts to move forward. They want better lives for their children and use their strength to keep their children safe. The hopes and dreams of mothers continually include a healthy environment where their children are doing well in school and spending time with family.

“I don’t know... my life has been like a real struggle but I’ve come to realize it’s going to take a lot more than the situations that I’ve come through to stop me from doing what I need to do to provide for my family.”[32]

THE NEED TO CREATE SAFE HOMES

Housing First is a promising model in the field of homelessness within Canada. It works to move those experiencing housing issues directly into their own independent house or apartment, with subsequent supports. This approach offers the most promise when adapted to the needs of particulars groups and communities. Two examples of such adaptations include:

  1. Nikihk Housing First, Bent Arrow Traditional Healing Society – A program based out of Homeward Trust in Edmonton that addresses Indigenous homelessness. It considers how to integrate Indigenous culture into Housing First, including being representative of diverse Indigenous teachings, maintaining connections to local Indigenous groups, and having an inclusive governance structure
  2. The Vivian – A Housing First program from RainCity Housing and Support Society in Vancouver. The Vivian is by women, and for women. It employs a harm reduction approach and its first goal is to provide a safe house in order to prevent violence while living on the streets[33]

LEARNING FROM LIVED EXPERIENCE

A MUST READ!

Women’s Shelters Canada created a list of 11 recommendations for the fall 2017 National Housing Strategy entitled Housing, Homelessness, & Violence Against Women (VAW).

Their work is grounded in an intersectional gender-based analysis and was developed through a cross-sectoral roundtable on housing, homelessness, and VAW. Their recommendations include pieces on the national housing fund, investments in affordable housing, and a homelessness partnering strategy.[36]


WRITTEN BY

Linda Baker, Learning Director
Dianne Lalonde, Research Associate
Jassamine Tabibi, Research Associate

WE ARE GRATEFUL FOR THE INPUT AND CONTRIBUTIONS OF

Dr. Alex Abramovich, Scientist, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health | Assistant Professor, University of Toronto
Jesse Donaldson and Stephanie Vasko, Canadian Observatory on Homelessness
Krittika Ghosh, Ontario Council of Agencies Serving Immigrants
Cora McGuire-Cyrette, Ontario Native Women’s Association
Fran Odette, Independent Consultant

GRAPHIC DESIGN

Elsa Barreto, Multi-media Specialist, Centre for Research & Education on Violence Against Women & Children, Western University

ISBN

978-1-988412-14-6

PLEASE EVALUATE THIS NEWSLETTER!

Let us know what you think. Your input is important to us. Please complete this brief survey on your thoughts of this newsletter: https://uwo.eu.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_dbAhzEuaWkPKPpb

CONTACT US!

vawlearningnetwork.ca

twitter.com/learntoendabuse

facebook.com/TheLearningNetwork

Contact vawln@uwo.cato join our email list!

REFERENCES

[1] Employment and Social Development Canada. 2017. Homelessness Partnering Strategy: Highlights – 2016 Coordinated Point-in-Time Count of Homelessness in Canadian Communities. Available online: https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/programs/communities/homelessness/reports/highlights-2016-point-in-time-count.html

[2] Ibid.

[3] Learning Network. 2015. Intersectionality Newsletter. Available online: http://www.vawlearningnetwork.ca/issue-15-intersectionality

[4] Canadian Observatory on Homelessness. 2012. Canadian definition of Homelessness. Available online: http://www.homelesshub.ca/sites/default/files/COHhomelessdefinition.pdf

[5] Crenshaw, Kimberle. 1991. Mapping the margins: Intersectionality, identity politics, and violence against women of color. Stanford Law Review 43 (6): 1241-99.

[6] Tutty, L., Cindy Ogden, B., & G. Weaver-Dunlop. 2013. I built my house of hope: Abused women and pathways into homelessness. Violence Against Women 19 (12): 1498-517, p. 1510.

[7] Tutty et al., 2013, p.1509.

[8] O'Campo, P., Nihaya Daoud, S., & J. Dunn. 2016. Conceptualizing housing instability: Experiences with material and psychological instability among women living with partner violence. Housing Studies 31 (1): 1-19, p.7.

[9] Noble, A. 2014. Child and family homelessness: Building a comprehensive framework to address child and family homelessness in Canada: Phase 1, an environmental scan. Toronto: Raising the Roof. Available online: http://www.raisingtheroof.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/RtR_EnvScan_March2014-FINAL.pdf

[10] O’Campo et al., 2016, p.7.

[11] Statistics Canada. 2013. Homeownership and Shelter Costs in Canada. Available online: http://www12.statcan.gc.ca/nhs-enm/2011/as-sa/99-014-x/99-014-x2011002-eng.pdf    

[12] Ibid.

[13] Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation. 2006. Housing Discrimination Against Victims of Domestic Violence. Socio-economic Series 06-010. Available online: https://www.cmhc-schl.gc.ca/odpub/pdf/65096.pdf

[14] Abramovich, Alex. 2016. Preventing, reducing and ending LGBTQ2S youth homelessness: The need for targeted strategies. Social Inclusion 4 (4): 86-96.

[15] Barata, P. & Stewart, D. 2010. Searching for housing as a battered woman: Does discrimination affect reported availability of a rental unit? Psychology of Women Quarterly 34 (1): 43-55.

[16] Beattie, S. & Hutchins, H. 2015. Shelters for abused women in Canada 2014. Statistics Canada (Catalogue number 85-002-X Juristat). Available online:

http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/85-002-x/2015001/article/14207-eng.htm

[17] Ibid.

[18] Moffitt, P., H. Fikowski, M. Mauricio, & A. Mackenzie. 2013. Intimate partner violence in the Canadian territorial north: Perspectives from a literature review and a media watch. International Journal of Circumpolar Health 72 (1): 215-21; Waegemakers Schiff, J. & Turner, A. (2014). Housing first in rural Canada: Rural homelessness and housing first feasibility across 22 Canadian communities. Available online: http://homelesshub.ca/sites/default/files/Rural_Homelessness_in_Canada_2014.pdf

[19] Tutty et al., 2013, p.1506.

[20] Ontario Human Rights Commission. 2008. Right at home: Report on the consultation on human rights and rental housing in Ontario. Available online: http://www.ohrc.on.ca/en/right-home-report-consultation-human-rights-and-rental-housing-ontario/housing-discrimination-and-individual

[21] Thurston, W.. A. Roy, B. Clow, D. Este, T. Gordey , M. Haworth-Brockman, L. McCoy, R. Rapaport Beck, C. Saulnier & L. Carruthers 2013. Pathways Into and Out of Homelessness: Domestic Violence and Housing Security for Immigrant Women. Journal of Immigrant & Refugee Studies 11 (3): 278-298, p.290.

[22] Tutty et al., 2013, p.1511.

[23] Tutty et al., 2013, p. 1507.

[24] Daoud, N., F. Matheson, C. Pedersen, S. Hamilton-Wright, A. Minh, J. Zhang, & P. O'Campo. 2016. Pathways and trajectories linking housing instability and poor health among low-income women experiencing intimate partner violence (IPV): Toward a conceptual framework. Women & Health 56 (2): 208-25, p.217.

[25] Tutty et al., 2013, p.1507.

[26] Tutty et al., 2013, p.1510.

[27] O’Campo et al., 2016, p.13.

[28] O’Campo et al., 2016, p.13.

[29] O’Campo et al., 2016, p.7.

[30] Davis, R. 2002. "The Strongest Women": Exploration of the Inner Resources of Abused Women. Qualitative Health Research 12 (9): 1248-63, p.1249.

[31] Ontario Native Women’s Association and Ontario Federation of Indigenous Friendship Centres. 2015. Breaking Free, Breaking Through. Available online: http://www.onwa.ca/upload/documents/resources/breaking-free-breaking-through-report.pdf

[32] Milaney, K., Ramage, K., Yang Fang, X., & M. Louis. 2017. Understanding Mothers Experiencing Homelessness: A Gendered Approach to Finding Solutions to Family Homelessness. Toronto: Canadian Observatory on Homelessness Press. Available online: http://homelesshub.ca/familyhomelessness

[33] Gaetz, S., Scott, F., & T. Gulliver (Eds.). 2013. Housing First in Canada: Supporting Communities to End Homelessness. Toronto: Canadian Observatory on Homelessness Press. Available online: http://www.homelesshub.ca/sites/default/files/HousingFirstInCanada.pdf

[34] Paradis, E., Bardy, S., Cummings-Diaz, P., Athumani, A. & I. Pereira. 2011. We’re not asking, we’re telling: An inventory of practices promoting the dignity, autonomy, and self-determination of women and families facing homelessness. Toronto: The Canadian Observatory on Homelessness Press. Available online: http://homelesshub.ca/sites/default/files/goodpractice_report.pdf

[35] All Our Sisters - http://www.alloursisters.ca

[36] Maki K. & Women’s Shelters Canada. Housing, Homelessness, and Violence Against Women: A Discussion Paper. Available Online: http://homelesshub.ca/sites/default/files/Housing%2C%20Homelessness%2C%20and%20VAW%20Discussion%20Paper%20Aug%202017.pdf